Vinyl vs. Cedar Shake Siding: Which Is Right For Your Canadian Home?

Choosing new siding is about more than updating the look of your home, it is about finding the right balance of style, durability, maintenance, and cost. Two popular options for Canadian homeowners are vinyl siding and cedar shake siding. Each brings its own advantages and tradeoffs, and understanding the differences can help you make a choice that suits your home, lifestyle, and budget.

Understanding Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding is a manufactured product made from PVC, designed to mimic the look of traditional wood siding while offering far less maintenance. It is a popular choice across Canada because it stands up well to moisture, does not rot, and never needs to be painted. Modern vinyl siding comes in a wide range of profiles and colours, from subtle neutrals to bold tones, which makes it easy to match or refresh the style of your home.

In terms of day-to-day care, vinyl siding is very low maintenance. A gentle wash with a garden hose and mild soap is usually all that is needed to keep it looking clean. It is also relatively light and straightforward to install, which often makes it a cost-effective option for large projects or full exterior makeovers.

Understanding Cedar Shake Siding

Cedar shake siding is made from natural cedar wood that is split or sawn into textured pieces, creating a rich, handcrafted appearance. It is chosen for its natural beauty, warm tones, and the way it weathers gracefully over time. Many homeowners love cedar because it adds character and depth to traditional, cottage, or coastal style homes, and pairs beautifully with stone or brick accents.

However, cedar is a natural material, so it does require more maintenance than vinyl. To keep cedar shakes looking their best and to protect them from moisture, UV exposure, and insects, they should be stained or treated periodically. With proper care, cedar shake siding can last for many years, offering a unique, premium look that stands out in the neighbourhood.

Comparing Vinyl and Cedar Shake for Canadian Homes

Both vinyl and cedar shake siding can work well in Canadian climates, but they perform differently.

Vinyl siding is highly resistant to moisture and will not rot, which is a major advantage in areas with frequent rain or snow. It does not attract insects and does not require painting, which keeps long term upkeep simpler. In very cold temperatures, lower quality vinyl can become more brittle, so it is important to choose products suited to Canadian conditions and have them installed correctly.

Cedar shake siding provides natural insulation and has a timeless, high-end appearance that many homeowners find appealing. It can handle freeze and thaw cycles well when properly maintained, and its natural grain and variation create a look that vinyl can only imitate. The tradeoff is that cedar will ask more of you in terms of maintenance, and the upfront cost is generally higher than vinyl.

In short, vinyl tends to be the practical, low maintenance choice, while cedar shake is often selected for its beauty and character.

Choosing With Gerry’s Roofing & Siding

The right siding choice depends on your priorities. If you want minimal maintenance, a wide selection of colours, and strong value, vinyl siding may be your best fit. If you are drawn to natural materials, rich texture, and a classic, crafted look, cedar shake siding might be worth the added care.

Gerry’s Roofing & Siding helps homeowners in Ontario weigh these factors with clear information and real-world experience. Our team can walk you through style options, performance expectations, and long-term costs, then provide a detailed quote for each choice. Whether you decide on vinyl siding, cedar shake siding, or a combination of both, we install with care, protect your home during the project, and leave you with an exterior that looks beautiful and stands up to Canadian weather.

If you are ready to compare vinyl and cedar shake siding for your home, reach out to Gerry’s Roofing & Siding to discuss your options and request a free quote.